josietheschnauzer - No problems of which to speak makes for a good week! If you're doing an excellent job practicing the behaviors described in the MWL 10-Point Checklist, you are focusing your attention and energies correctly. I wouldn't draw too many conclusions based on a single week's weigh-in result, since many factors can influence any given scale reading. Keep strictly adhering to the guidelines and give yourself some time to see what feedback the scale provides over the next few weeks. Regarding how to know when you are at the "right weight," Dr. McDougall discusses that question in
this newsletter.
How Do You Tell If You’re the Right Weight?
Take off all of your clothes and stand in front of the mirror. Do you like what you see? All the weight charts in the world pale in importance to your own perceptions.
One Important Precaution. If you are too thin and have any concern that this might be a health issue then please check with your doctor. Illnesses, like cancer, infectious diseases (AIDS), liver and thyroid disease can also cause excessive weight loss. So can some serious psychological problems, like anorexia and depression.
In
this thread on Optimum BMI, Jeff reviews the evidence suggesting adults should try to maintain a BMI in the 18.5-22 range. Keep in mind -
JeffN wrote:There are many biomarkers used to help determine/evaluate someone's health.
These include (but not limited to)
BMI,
Waist Circumference
Waist to hip ratio
Waist to height ratio
Percentage Body Fat
Total Cholesterol
LDL
HDL
LDL/HDL
Total Cholesterol/HDL
Triglycerides
Blood sugar
insulin
Etc, etc
BMI is just one marker, as are all of the rest, and no one marker alone can predict someones health outcomes. And, they are just markers.
Or as the old saying goes, they are "fingers pointing to the moon" but not the "moon" itself.
I still think the "plate test" is the best test there is ![smile :)](./images/smilies/smile.gif)
Wildgoose describes how she determined her "goal weight" in
this post, which may be of interest. It may also be worthwhile to take a moment for a review of the MWL 10-Point Checklist, just to see if anything might be "slipping through the cracks;" since results are the product of adherence and time, if adherence is excellent allow more time.
Abe - One's rate of weight loss does tend to slow down over time, for all the reasons Jeff outlines
here. When facing a plateau, he recommends
JeffN wrote:a very honest and thorough appraisal of the guidelines and principles of the MWL program and calorie density and their understanding and adherence to them.
Then, make the recommended adjustments as needed.
Remember, the program always works because it is based on sound science and the laws of physics.
Your goals don't seem unreasonable to me, and the checklist outlines the behaviors that are most effective for achieving those goals in a healthful and sustainable way. Like I wrote to josie above, if adherence is excellent allow more time.
jan_npr - Congratulations on hitting that 5 pound mark! It looks like you had a good week, and I'm glad you are feeling like you are on the right track.
jan_npr wrote:I've been drinking water based cocoa a few times a week. How bad is this?
That depends on how much you are including and your own specific goals or concerns. Jeff has a thread
examining considerations and concerns with chocolate, including cocoa powder.
JeffN wrote:Cocoa is ~50% fat, ~30% saturated fat and ~1000 cal/lb. Most cocoa powders, including organic ones, are contaminated with heavy metals.
JeffN wrote:If someone wanted to include some cocoa, the safest way might be to find some pure cocoa powder that is not processed with alkali and limit its use to a serving (1 tbsp) per day.
JeffN wrote:In the bigger picture, a small amount of any cocoa on occasion is not likely harmful. However it is not a health food, and the fat, sat fat, heavy metals etc could add up quickly.
JeffN wrote:However, as I said in other threads, these 5% exceptions can add up fast and if you add in enough of them (oil, chocolate, wine, cheese, etc) the next thing you know they are making up the majority of your calories and the real food has been pushed to the side.
That exercise challenge sounds great! What is your plan for fitting exercise into your daily routine?
kirstykay - Modest progress is progress, nevertheless! It seems like you did the best you could, taking into account the directions from your surgeon and the need to accommodate your recovery and healing. Best of luck with your follow-up evaluation, and for a continuing smooth recovery.
AnnetteW - Kudos! That seems like a solid week of progress to me. Doing the best you can, within your own context, and feeling good about your progress and your choices seems really important; I think that is a great position from which to proceed, and you can always adjust choices as that context evolves.
rlechols - Another good week!!! Isn't it nice to feel happy both with where you are at and where you are heading? It seems like you've established a pattern of gradual, steady progress in a manner that feels sustainable for you.
NateKruse - Congratulations on your continuing progress! Those french fries sound very appetizing, and you seem to have your recipe down to a science - quick and easy. Depending on the quantity of "cheese" sauce you are using, and the specific recipe, this may be relevant -
Mark Cooper wrote:Jeff discusses nutritional yeast in
this thread. Nutritional yeast is ~1700 calories / lb (just as calorie dense as sugar), so if one were to choose to use it, it should be used very sparingly as a condiment, following the same guidelines as for sugar.
wstokes - Wow! That is a big number! Even if some of those lost pounds are "found" next time, if you're making continuing progress implementing the recommended behaviors, you are headed in the right direction.
chaz01 - Very exciting! Consistently exercising EVERY SINGLE DAY this year is absolutely something in which you should take pride; take a bow! It sounds like you did very well with the checklist, overall. We've had loads of greens in our CSA box here, as well; I've been very much enjoying all the variety in my monster salads.
Ejg - Nice loss and congratulations on what appears to have been a great week! You are definitely not alone in viewing a controlled environment as a key factor; removing temptations entirely can certainly make adherence more easily attainable. I think it is really fantastic that you were able to discuss things with your daughter and arrive at a satisfactory solution.
jnc - I'm glad to hear you are pleased and feel like you are getting on track! Continuing progress is the name of the game; you tackled some important areas this week and you know where to direct your focus in the week to come. Keep it up!
abible - Kudos! You know what you did well this week, and you have some clear opportunities you can "tighten up" to support your progress as you proceed.
Belana - It can be a challenge to keep the days straight under the shadow of covid-19, right? Best of luck making some opportunities for cycling!
pootsy - I hope your sister is doing well, that sounds like a stressful situation. If you need some extra motivation for nixing the dairy -
Dr. McDougall lays out some good reasons.
Heart disease, cancer, type-2 diabetes, arthritis, and infectious disease are only a few of the common consequences of drinking milk from other animal species.
I'm very relieved to hear that those Chubby Chips didn't require a call to the fire department!
pootsy wrote:Sometimes easy ensures success.
So true!
gracezw - Welcome! I'm thrilled you are joining us! Continue putting the MWL 10-Point Checklist to good use; I tend to eat a substantial volume of food each day, as well, and MWL has really made a difference for me.
Judy_Bell - Kudos on your progress! Would a simple daily walk possibly work for you, as a way to fit exercise into your routine? I think it can be pretty common for motivation to waver somewhat, as the rate of weight loss starts to slow. Contrarily, this is exactly when greater attention to behavior is necessary for continued progress. If you can frame your idea of progress on practicing the appropriate behaviors, to the best of your ability, it can be a way to free yourself from the de-motivating influence of factors outside your control. Continue to apply yourself to overcoming those struggles you highlight - doing an excellent job can be quite motivating. Time invested in adequate preparation is always time well spent.
taymariekay - Way to go! It seems as though you are getting everything "dialed-in" in the ways that work for you right now, and you know those areas where you can make some adjustments, if needed. Keep it up!
Sue Ancora-imparo - Those tough weeks do happen - celebratory occasions often present challenges. As you said, an unusual week; using a habit tracker to keep up with the MWL 10-Point Checklist sounds like a great idea - a good way to make those beneficial behaviors your "usual."
Hope410 - You had a pretty successful fortnight, it seems! Way to go working on that exercise habit!
![thumbsup :thumbsup:](./images/smilies/thumbsup.gif)
Celebrations can certainly be fraught with temptation.
Hope410 wrote:My lesson was: NO non-compliant food in the house until MWL WOE is firmly established.
That seems like an excellent takeaway.
lmggallagher - Way to go, Michelle! You are making the checklist work for you! I hope those injured toes aren't hurting you too terribly, and you experience some relief from those other pain reactions. I'm pretty certain this WOE has been a significant factor in mitigating my CRPS symptoms (although they are substantial, I'm not nearly as debilitated as many with CRPS). It can be so strange having the delayed reactions like you describe, and I've certainly found it very much a "moving target" and an ongoing project to narrow down what helps vs. hinders in my own situation.